The current big news in the music education sector is the launch (finally!) of the National Centre for Arts Education (NCAE).
Following the centre’s introduction to the sector via the Music Mark Big Meet, like many of you, I have thoughts! Initially I shared some of these as a video which you can find on my LinkedIn and Instagram, or our YouTube channel, but having pushed the limits of the medium by going on for 7 minutes, I thought the full contents of my brain as regards this matter were better downloaded in written form…
The cynics amongst us could see the development of this centre as largely a paper-shuffling exercise; moving from a national plan to a national centre, and moving music hubs from oversight by ACE to oversight by the NCAE, in an effort to look like a new(ish) government is doing something different from the old. However, that does not necessarily mean that it won’t be a positive move, particularly since it heralds a national strategy approach for arts subjects that haven’t benefited from the level of attention that music has had over the last couple of decades.
Those of an optimistic frame of mind will be pleased that the centre appears to be setting out with much less of a ‘closed shop’ mentality than previous government initiatives for music. There is to be an open application process starting in November for teachers to join the centre’s subject panels, with these convening from January to help shape the centre’s work. It will be brilliant if this results in real teachers from real schools having a real say in how national policy is shaped, rather than the same old faces with (collectively) their rather narrow range of experience dictating a direction of travel which historically (looking at you, Model Music Curriculum) has not served schools well. However… the more times you have been put on a government panel, the more experience you have to show of being on a government panel, and therefore the more you are likely to look like the best candidate for the job just by virtue of having been selected for a government panel before. I hope someone has thought about that in the design of the person specification for the panel roles so that we don’t end up with the same group of people once again by default. And if not, perhaps someone could forward them the quote about the definition of insanity being doing the same thing repeatedly and expecting a different result…
Based on the presentation we saw in the meeting, the centre seems to have firmly fixed on school-employed teachers as its main focus. This is no surprise, following as it does much in the vein of the most recent national plan, which also refocused attention on teaching within and by schools. I wholeheartedly agree that this is the right focus; at the risk of going blue in the face yet again, let me reiterate my fervent belief that the only place we can guarantee making an impact on every child is within the curriculum. Enrichment activities are great, outreach is great, but not all children take part in these. If we want to change things for each and every child, the statutory curriculum is the only place to do it. (And yes, I know that even then it won’t include children educated outside the school system!)
All that said, it does then make the fact that NCAE is to take over responsibility for Music Hubs from September 2027 feel a little incongruous. I think they will need to work hard to integrate these two approaches so that the hubs aspect of their work doesn’t become a bolt-on anomaly. I know colleagues in the room were concerned that the centre team didn’t seem to understand what hubs do. I think that might have been the product of them providing the wrong presentation for the assembled audience, rather than anything more sinister, which is perhaps understandable given that responsibility for hubs won’t form part of their work until September 2027. There is, however, a role for Music Mark and indeed ACE and the DfE, to double-check that the work of hubs is fully understood by the centre well before September. On a positive note, the DfE were very clear that hubs are intended to be around for as long as the centre is, so we can at least expect another 6 years’ worth of hub activity, albeit still delivered on those unhelpful one-year funding agreements.
Another area of understanding which I think the centre needs to develop is around the real barriers to continuing professional development. There is to be a mapping exercise looking at what CPD is currently available across the country, a network of Lead Arts Schools to be set up, and work to be carried out with the Chartered College of Teaching to develop a Professional Development Framework that will be used to commission, QA and create CPD provision. None of this is necessarily a bad thing but it does rather fundamentally miss the point. I cannot of course speak for the other arts subjects, but for music, there is no shortage of CPD available at local, regional, and national level. The issue teachers have is not that there isn’t CPD available for them, it’s that there is and they can’t access it! The recruitment and retention crisis, and funding and budget issues within schools caused by rising costs and falling birthrate, means that it is becoming almost impossible to release teachers for any kind of training. And the answer to that isn’t producing ‘free online training’ for teachers to do in, you know, all that spare time they have…
If we want to get serious about upskilling teachers in the arts, there are two problems to solve. The first is the lack of arts (and indeed most Foundation subjects) content in Initial Teacher Training. If we don’t sort this, then any CPD provision is effectively just an attempt to shut the stable door after the horse has bolted. The second is fixing the systemic barriers to accessing CPD. The centre of course does not hold the purse strings, but there is a role here for them to explain to government that simply signposting to or creating more CPD without fixing the issues around the costs and availability of cover, teacher workload, and accountability measures steering schools into prioritising other subjects, is almost pointless. Put those two issues together and we could be staring down endless decades of throwing good money after bad as we try and tackle a problem that could have been fixed at the source. What was that definition of insanity again….?
Obviously the centre has been given a brief by the government, and their job is to fulfil that brief. It would be unfair to hold a two-week-old organisation to account for decisions that they have been landed with rather than participated in. Given some of the people involved – such as the brilliant Louisa Roberts – I am sure they will make the best of the job they’ve been given. It is a good thing to have a national centre promoting the importance of arts education, and certainly better to have one than not! But how much more impact could such a centre have on children and young people’s experiences of the arts in schools, and how much easier might that job be, if we tackled the systemic issues getting in the way first?
Dr Liz Stafford. October 2026. Copyright © 2026 Music Education Solutions Limited. All Rights Reserved.
Click here to read more blogs about music education
Click here to explore our services for schools
Click here to join our mailing list
